| 1995 Canaday Farm Altmont, NY. Judge: George Gardner | ||
| CLASS | CHAMPION | RESERVE CHAMPION |
| Novice-Novice | Brooks Parrott & Skye | Sharon Nunan & Jim |
| Pro-Novice | Bev Lambert & Spy | Walt Jagger & McDuff |
| Ranch | Gene Sheninger & Yankee | Walt Jagger & Nan |
| 1996 Canaday Farm Altmont, NY. Judge: Bruce Fogt | ||
| CLASS | CHAMPION | RESERVE CHAMPION |
| Novice-Novice | Barbra Levinson & Jim | Jim Strohecker & Rudy |
| Pro-Novice | Walt Jagger & Jim | Merry Klimek & Tweed |
| Ranch | Russ Middaugh & Marvin | Mary Brighoff & Moss |
| 1997 Taravale Farm, Esperance, NY. Judge: Eve Marshark | ||
| CLASS | CHAMPION | RESERVE CHAMPION |
| Novice-Novice | Louise Demarcello & Sally | Sue Schoen & Jet |
| Pro-Novice | Barbra Levinson & Ivy | Walt Jagger & Moss |
| Ranch | Barbara Leverett & Queen | Walt Jagger & Jim |
| 1998 Sheriff's Youth Ranch, Marstons Mills, MA. Judge: JP LaLonde | ||
| CLASS | CHAMPION | RESERVE CHAMPION |
| Novice-Novice | Kate Collins & Buddha | Lindy Elkins & Tess |
| Pro-Novice | Jean Kennedy & Beth | Mike Canaday & Tip |
| Ranch | Barbara Leverett & Queen | Derek Johnson & Kelly |
| 1999 Bittersweet Farm, Hampton, CT. Judge: Bernie Armata | ||
| CLASS | CHAMPION | RESERVE CHAMPION |
| Novice-Novice | Karen Agazzi & Megan | Mark Billadeau & Dot |
| Pro-Novice | Rich Seamans & Zoe | Rennee Billadeau & Moss |
| Ranch | Bev Lambert & Kit | Fiona Robertson & Jess |
| 2000 Taravale Farm, Esperance, NY. Judge: Bruce Smart | ||
| CLASS | CHAMPION | RESERVE CHAMPION |
| Novice-Novice | Gail Jaffa & Trace | Stephen Paxton-Hill & Kiss |
| Pro-Novice | Joyce Geier & Tait | Bar Armata & Jazz |
| Ranch | Michael Dathe & Cooper | Paul Heidenburg & Jodi |
| 2001 Sheepy Hollow Farm, PA. Judge: JP LaLonde | ||
| CLASS | CHAMPION | RESERVE CHAMPION |
| Novice-Novice | Mark Billadeau & Blue | Jim Murphy & Megan |
| Pro-Novice | Mary Brighoff & Jaff | Mary Brighoff & Ned |
| Ranch | Brooks Parrot & Moss | Renee Billadeau & Moss |
| 2002 Soule Homestead, Middleboro,MA. Judge: Bill Strang | ||
| CLASS | CHAMPION | RESERVE CHAMPION |
| Novice-Novice | Nancy Obernier & Wattie | Susan Cullen & Nick |
| Pro-Novice | Rich Seaman & Kess | Betty Levin & Bryn |
| Ranch | Sue Schoen & Clair | Joan Worthington & Sam |
| 2003 Alix Cleveland and Tom Meagher's Farm, Nicholson,PA. Judge: Bernie Armata |
||
| CLASS | CHAMPION | RESERVE CHAMPION |
| Novice-Novice | Annie Palmer & Kim | Pat Warne & Nell |
| Pro-Novice | Mary Ann Kras & Gyp | Gene Sheninger & Gail |
| Ranch | Sally Molloy & Zac | Heather Millen & Spy |
| 2004 Fosterfields Living Historical Farm Morristown,NJ. Judge: Maria Mick |
||
| CLASS | CHAMPION | RESERVE CHAMPION |
| Novice-Novice | Joanne Murphy & Bess | Emma Court & Kane |
| Pro-Novice | Mary Thompson & Holly | Joanne Murphy & Maude |
| Ranch | Emma Court & Marshall | Mary Brighoff & Don |
| 2005 Hopkinton Fairgrounds,Contoocook,NH. Judge: Carol Campion | ||
| CLASS | CHAMPION | RESERVE CHAMPION |
| Novice-Novice | Nathalie Labelle & Tyke | Elin Rusconi-Black & Stevie |
| Pro-Novice | Peter Vandecar & Russ | Claire Garwood & Rhos |
| Ranch | Dave Lewis & AJ | Jim Murphy & Megan |
| 2006 Taravale Farm,Esperance,NY. Judge: Lorna Savage | ||
| CLASS | CHAMPION | RESERVE CHAMPION |
| Novice-Novice | Heidi Fuge & Gar | Anne Devine & Sue |
| Pro-Novice | Warren Mick & Sweep | Sue Schoen & Tyne |
| Ranch | Jim Murphy & Trim | Warren Mick & Dale |
| 2007 High Point Farm,Knox,NY. Judge: George Northrup | ||
| CLASS | CHAMPION | RESERVE CHAMPION |
| Novice-Novice | Lori Mauger & Mia | Linda Comeau & Roy |
| Pro-Novice | Joyce Geier & Jim | Pat Hammel-Murphy & Bob |
| Ranch | Warren Mick & Dale | Ian Talbot & Maeve |